peanut butter cookie

the best peanut butter cookies

last updated on October 29, 2026

peanut butter cookie

Say goodbye to the days of dry peanut butter cookies because today I am sharing the best peanut butter cookies ever! They are thick, dense, and packed with peanut butter m&m’s, so they really are the best.

I don’t know about you, but I feel like whenever I try a peanut butter cookie, it is usually dry! I am a big fan of peanut butter, so I want to like peanut butter cookies whenever I try them, but I can’t stand a dry cookie. So I decided to take matters into my own hands and make a peanut butter cookie that is far from dry. These cookies are baked at a high temperature which makes them cook quickly on the outside, leaving the middle nice and soft. My mom has tried most of my cookies and said that these are her favorite, so if that doesn’t convince you to try these I don’t know what will!

ingredients needed for the best peanut butter cookies

  • butter
  • brown sugar
  • creamy peanut butter
  • eggs
  • vanilla extract
  • flour
  • cornstarch
  • baking soda
  • salt
  • peanut butter m&m’s

tips for making the best peanut butter cookies

These cookies are large, ok? They are a whopping 6oz large! The large size is what helps them to be so ooey-gooey on the inside. The best way to measure out the dough is to use a kitchen scale! If you don’t have one, I highly recommend getting one. This is the one I use and it works great!

Once you’ve weighed out your cookies, the next step is to shape them. I like to shape these cookies into a rough ball / cylinder. I say cylinder because I like to shape them so they are rounded around the edges and rough on top, in a cylinder shape.

With these cookies, you’ll want to let them cool completely. Since these cookies are so large, they need time for the inside to fully set up! If you simply can’t wait, dive into one to hold you over while the rest of them set up.

My last tip is about the type of peanut butter to use — it is best to use your classic creamy peanut butter! We’re talking Jif or Skippy!

stack of peanut butter cookies

other recipes you’ll love

the best peanut butter cookies

peanut butter cookie
[category] Dessert
[published] May 11, 2022
[PREP] 30 minutes
[COOK] 10 minutes
[TOTAL] 40 minutes

Ingredients

  • 1 cup butter cold
  • 1 1/2 cups brown sugar dark or light is fine
  • 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 2 eggs
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 3 cups all-purpose flour (390 grams)
  • 3 tbsp cornstarch
  • 1 tsp baking soda
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • 1 cup peanut butter m&ms

Instructions

  1. Preheat the oven to 400 F. Add the butter and brown sugar to a bowl or stand mixer. Mix for 2-3 minutes until fully combined and creamy. Add peanut butter and mix another minute. Add eggs and vanilla extract. Mix until just combined.
  2. Add flour, cornstarch, baking soda, and salt. Mix until just combined. Add peanut butter m&ms and mix until they're just distributed through the dough.
  3. Using a kitchen scale, scoop out 6 ounce of dough and form into a rough ball. Place up to 6 dough balls on a lined or lightly greased cookie sheet.
  4. Bake for 9-11 minutes until cookies are just starting to brown. Let the cookies cool on the baking sheet for 5 minutes, then transfer to a cooling rack to cool completely.
  5. Keep any extra cookies in a sealable container. Enjoy!!

What’d you think? I’d love to hear your thoughts or if you have any questions!

Rating




Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Sofia Polanco
    Reply

    These are sooooo goood! I made these with a vegan flax egg and they turned out amazing!

    1. thepalatablelife
      Reply

      hi! i’m so so glad!! i’m glad to know that they worked with a flax egg!

  2. Sofia Polanco
    Reply

    These are sooooo goood! I made these with a vegan flax egg and they turned out amazing!

    1. thepalatablelife
      Reply

      hi! i’m so so glad!! i’m glad to know that they worked with a flax egg!

  3. Emily
    Reply

    I took these into the office one day (and thank god because I would have eaten all of them if I kept them at home..) and they were a HIT. This is my favorite cookie recipe ever because it’s simple enough but everyone seems to agree this is everything they want out of a peanut butter cookie and more. Absolutely obsessed!

    1. thepalatablelife
      Reply

      YAY that makes me so happy! and so kind of you to share them with your co-workers. glad these were enjoyed!!

  4. Emily
    Reply

    I took these into the office one day (and thank god because I would have eaten all of them if I kept them at home..) and they were a HIT. This is my favorite cookie recipe ever because it’s simple enough but everyone seems to agree this is everything they want out of a peanut butter cookie and more. Absolutely obsessed!

    1. thepalatablelife
      Reply

      YAY that makes me so happy! and so kind of you to share them with your co-workers. glad these were enjoyed!!

  5. Carrie
    Reply

    Can you make these in advance and freeze them? How would you do so? Freeze them raw or baked? Also, if I wanted them for let’s say, Christmas Eve, when is the best time to bake them? Thanks!

    1. thepalatablelife
      Reply

      hi! i would recommend freezing the dough balls, then baking them day of! just keep the dough balls in an airtight container! they may need an extra 1-2 minutes of baking time since they will be starting from so cold. hope you enjoy!

  6. Ludovica
    Reply

    I truly loved this recipe! My husband, friends and family enjoyed the cookies and left no crumbs. It’s simple and extremely tasty! Love, forme Italy

    1. thepalatablelife
      Reply

      yay that makes me so happy! so glad you enjoyed!

  • day 6: brussels sprout salad!!

you only need one fresh vegetable on your thanksgiving table and this one is perfect. it’s bright, crunchy, and light. and if you’ve never had thinly sliced brussels sprouts, i promise they are actually yummy!! trust!

recipe is on my website, in my bio! or comment “recipe” and i’ll send it straight to you 💫☁️

#thanksgiving #thanksgivingdinner #friendsgiving #brusselssprouts #saladrecipe
  • day 5: raspberry cream pie!

fluffy, bright, not too sweet — truly the perfect pie to balance out any dessert table! recipe is on my website, in my bio! or comment “recipe” and i’ll send it straight to you ☁️💫

#thanksgiving #thanksgivingrecipes #thanksgivingdesserts #pierecipe #raspberrycreampie
  • day 4: cauliflower gratin!

the most dreamy, cheesy, oniony side dish out there ☁️

recipe is on my website in my bio (malloryoniki.com). or comment “recipe” and i’ll send it to your dms!!

#thanksgiving #thanksgivingdinner #thanksgivingsides #friendsgiving #cauliflowergratin
  • day 3: nutella cheesecake!!

this has been a favorite in past years, so i had to bring it back again this year. this pie is RICH, but that just means it will go far because everyone just needs a tiny slice. but i promise everyone will be so happy to have chocolate/cookie option on their dessert table 🙂‍↕️🍪

full recipe is on my website, in my bio! or comment “recipe” and i’ll send it to your dms 💫

#thanksgiving #thanksgivingdesserts #nutellacheesecake #friendsgiving #nutella
  • day 2: fluffy milk bread rolls!!

i have been tweaking and working on this recipe for months and it’s finally ready. the most perfect milk bread rolls that truly are little clouds. one batch makes 12 rolls but you may wanna double or triple it cause these will go quick!!!

full recipe (including overnight instructions) are on my website, linked in my bio! or comment “recipe” and i’ll dm it to you ☁️💫

#thanksgivingrecipes #friendsgiving #milkbread #dinnerrolls #milkbreadrolls
  • miso snickerdoodles for my @utahroyalsfc girls!!

their first playoff game is tomorrow which is HUGE as it’s the first time in club history they’ve made the playoffs 🩰🏆🌟💗⚽️💋 and no what team you root for, you should tune into the @nwsl playoffs because EVERYONE WATCHES WOMEN’S SPORTS!

+ these miso snickerdoodles are one of my favorites from my whole book — if you don’t have a copy yet, it’s linked in my bio! 

#womenssoccer #nwsl #cookierecipes #snickerdoodles

@malloryoniki